Giving
Criticism in a Positive Manner
Oxymoron, you
say? I don’t think so! You have to tell your people when they’re
performing less than great – and you can tell them how they need to
improve without making them feel like idiots.
No one likes to
tell an employee that her sensitive feelings get in the way of
productivity, or that another employee has to pay more attention to side
work and not try to sneak out before it’s all done. There are so many
issues that could be talked about here because you have so many different
people working for you. They’re from different backgrounds and belief
systems and they all have their own unique personalities. And that’s the
wonder of life - all those unique personalities!
Remember a time
when we tried to make us all the same by calling us “waitrons?” Waitron
sounds like a servant robot – not at all what anyone ever wants his/her
servers to be! At least I hope not! Be glad we’re all different!
Ok, now the
wonder ends. You have to deal with those unique personalities on a day to
day basis and try to make them all work together as harmoniously as
possible. No small task! How do you handle Myra’s chronic attitude
problem in the early morning hours? How do you handle Jack’s consistent
skating on side work?
Most people
respond to flattery – sincere flattery – and a little bit of it goes a
long way. Before you start reprimanding Jack for his slacker attitude
toward side work, give him a sincere compliment. It should flow into the
perceived problem without sounding like a big “BUT” kind of speech. Start
with phrases such as:
- “I think it’s
great that you remember your regular customers’ names…”
- “Guests are so
appreciative when you…”
- “I wish
everyone had your natural knack for selling wine…”
The idea is to be
specific and be truly appreciative of the good qualities. After your
initial compliment, you have to bring up the problem or opportunity for
improvement. A good way to start that is by saying, “We seem to be having
a problem with side work. I’ve noticed that you kind of lose your energy
and leave your side work unfinished. We’re all tired after a busy shift
and it isn’t fair to leave before all the work done. We all suffer when
things aren’t completed.” You might offer help: “I’m sure you don’t do
this on purpose. Just to help you remember, I need you to check with me
before you leave and I’ll check you out.” Most of us don’t appreciate
having to do a special check-out, separate from the others. It makes us
feel singled out and watched and sometimes that’s just the deterrent you
need! Start with small “punishment,” for lack of a better word, and move
into bigger stuff as necessary.
Beginning the
conversation with an employee with a moody temperament might start like
this: “Myra, I notice that you aren’t always in the best mood when you
come in in the mornings. When you come in and don’t smile and slam doors
and just generally don’t seem happy, we and your customers feel like we
can’t approach you. We’re a little afraid of you. Is there something
about mornings you don’t like? Is there something we can do to help you
be happier?” If Myra realizes her attitude is noticed and not
appreciated, she may have to decide if a morning job is for her. On the
other hand, it may be something as simple as Jack not leaving enough
opening items for her to begin the day. Some people don’t realize they
can ask questions; they get into bad moods instead.
Obviously, these
situations are simplistic, both in approach and in solution. Problems are
never black and white. Sometimes if you ask a lot of questions that
require more than just “yes” or “no,” you can find out what is really
going on with an employee.
This can work in
your quarterly reviews or whenever the need arises. You have to ask Jack
if he can stay after his shift today because there a couple of things you
want to go over with him. Don’t make a big deal out of it and neither
will Jack. Keep your attitude light and personable; condescension or a
scolding tone will insure a defensive attitude.
If you have a
good rapport with your staff, you can talk to them about anything and
avoid scolding sessions. Myra may require a different approach than Jack
and Scott may require yet another approach. This is your business and you
obviously care about it. Show your employees you care and talk to them
about their performances. If they know you care about them, they will
learn to care about you and the restaurant they represent.
I have
restaurant training
manuals available for sale, as well as my new book, “A Waiter’s Training,”
for the individual server who wants to learn more about his/her career and
improve on skills. You can visit my store at
http://www.waiter-training.com/order.html.
Training and
information is the key! Contact me, Susie, at Waiter Training, either by
phone or email. My business number is (720) 203-4615, and web address
http://www.waiter-training.com.
Susie Ross has been
involved in the hospitality industry for ten years